Key considerations in choosing a community-owned solar garden
Last updated 7/24/2019
As solar photovoltaic (PV) systems become increasingly affordable and ‘Virtual’ Net Metering and other community solar-friendly policies are introduced in more states, more companies and utilities are beginning to offer community-owned solar power gardens. As options grow, it will be important that you as a solar shopper know what to look for in order to get the best deal.
“A solar installation at your property – roof-mount or ground-mount - is likely to offer you the best financial benefits and you should consider that option before considering a community-owned solar garden. Nevertheless, we recommend that you comparison-shop the available options to ensure you’re getting the solution that offers you the best value.”
Finding a community solar project
At this point in time, with the concept and the market still relatively new, there may not be many community solar options available in your community.
However, as the name indicates, one of the things that makes community-owned solar interesting and unique is that community-owned solar projects can be built in virtually every community. If you are interested in kick-starting a community solar garden for your own community, reading through NREL’s report on the topic is a good place to start.
Key considerations in selecting a community solar program
How much money will you save?
Community-owned solar gardens are distinct from Green Power programs, which charge a premium price for switching a home or business’s electricity supply to renewables. The purpose of a community solar power project should ultimately be to save you money—whether you purchase a share of the solar panels or a stake in the project, or you subscribe to buy the electricity produced from the solar garden.
An increasing number of states are implementing policies to allow Virtual Net Metering (VNM), which is a key policy that enables community solar programs. VNM ensures that participants receive on-bill solar credits for each unit of solar power that their share of the solar garden produces—even if the panels are not located on their own property. The amount of this credit is equal to the participant’s utility rates— for e.g., if someone pays 10¢ per unit (kilowatt-hour or kWh), they will receive a credit for 10¢ for each kWh of solar produced (the actual credit may vary slightly to account for transmission and distribution losses).
As time goes on, however, more and more project developers and utilities will find ways to make community-owned solar a viable option even without VNM, mainly by assigning alternative values to the solar power generated by the project—rates that are not connected to your electricity tariffs.
Purchase a Share of the Solar Garden
If you have purchased a share in the Community solar garden, your panels will pay for themselves’ as the system produces power and almost eliminate your monthly utility bills. As with rooftop solar, it is important to understand the return on your investment, how long it will take until payoff is reached, after which point all power produced will be ‘free’ for the remainder of the system’s life.
While the cost of building a large solar installation is significantly less than the cost of installing a small solar PV system at a home, the overhead cost may be higher if the land where panels are installed is rented or purchased Additionally, the solar farm operator may still be responsible for maintaining the solar installation. They may either charge you upfront fees or annual fees to maintain the system. These costs can impact your savings and payback periods. A point to remember, you will still be able to benefit from the available tax credits.
If you do not own, but rather sign up for a subscription to a community-owned solar program, your savings of may be lower. The upside, of course, is that you will not be required to purchase the system up-front, and may start saving from day one.
Subscription to a community solar garden may have similarities to a solar lease or PPAagreement: the project developer/administrator is responsible for the solar installation and maintenance costs, and sells the electricity to you at a rate that is lower than what the utility offers. Both you and the developer share the savings generated by the community solar garden.
It is important for you to understand how much you will pay for the solar electricity from the solar garden and how much you will save every year. Solar power, being a fuel-free electricity source, is not subject to the price increases associated with electricity generated by power plants that run on gas or coal. The community solar garden developer / administrator may choose to charge you a higher rate every year you subscribe to electricity from them. These increased prices more likely reflect an increase in their revenue than a need to cover increasing costs.
This is especially true in cases where the price you pay is linked to the electricity rates charged by the utility —for example, the solar garden may offer you a 5% or 10% discount on the rates from the utility. As the utility prices increase every year, the price you pay for electricity from the solar garden will also rise. Some programs may instead ‘lock in’ a set rate for solar over the duration of the contract, with or without gradual increases tied to an agreed-upon electricity price inflation rate. Of the available programs, fixed-rate arrangements are clearly the most beneficial for you.
How much of your electricity will come from solar?
Although a community-owned solar garden will not send the electricity it generates directly to your home or business through a cable, community solar-friendly policies ensure that, when everything is accounted for, this is effectively what happens: Power produced from your share of the project is associated with your power bill, just as it would if the panels were on your roof or property. For this reason, it is reasonable to think of power from the solar garden as having been delivered directly to you.
Accordingly, your share in a community solar garden can and should be sized to meet your electricity needs. The community solar company will most likely ask for a copy of your electricity bills from the last 12 months. The allowable size of your share in the project—regardless of whether you own or subscribe—will typically be limited under program rules so that your solar production does not grossly exceed your actual electricity needs.
“Your share in the solar garden will typically be limited to the amount of electricity you use annually.”
What happens if you sell your house or move?
If you relocate within the same utility area, you will be able to keep your share of the solar garden. But if you move away from the utility service area where the solar garden is located, you may have to sell your share in the solar garden or pay an early exit fee if you have signed up for a subscription.
Does the program offer a performance monitoring option?
It is important that you are able to measure and track the amount of electricity your share of the community solar project is producing. This will provide you with a greater sense of satisfaction and certainty about the benefits. This is particularly important with community solar, where the flow of electricity and value is more abstract than with a rooftop system.
Who benefits from the sale of Solar Renewable Energy Certificates (SRECS)?
If you live in a state with an SREC market, you should inquire as to who gets the cash from the sale of these certificates. Depending on the pricing structure, they might be bundled into upfront costs associated with the solar garden, paid out to you on an ongoing basis, or retained by the solar company operating the solar garden.
Does the project encourage participation among low-income households?
State policies designed to facilitate community solar projects frequently mandate that a percentage of a project be carved out and allotted specifically for low-income households in order to make sure that the benefits of solar are shared by a broad section of the population.